Why “Jessie” is the Worst Show on Disney Channel

Cast17

For those who don’t know, this is a Disney Channel series about a girl from Texas who moves to New York City and becomes nanny for a Brangelina couple with four adopted children from around the world. If done well, it could allow for very educational programming for children about diversity and identity. Spoiler alert: it hasn’t been done well. It’s been done terribly.

Ravi wearing an Om shirt and presumably saying something in Hindi

Ravi wearing an Om shirt and probably speaking Hindi

Ravi is the newest addition to the family, recently adopted from India. He brought with him his water monitor (Mr. Kipling), whom he met as a baby. He talks with an exaggerated accent and is constantly referencing Ganesh, samosas, tigers, non-violence, fortune telling, and curry – to name a few. He teaches a yoga class and wears sherwanis.

This entire character is straight out of Edward Said’s Orientalism. Essentially, orientalism is when Westerners lump the entire continent of Asia into one foreign land with which they can associate everything they don’t understand. Things from this exotic land are instantly mystical and weird, because orientalists don’t understand them. This is okay, because orientalists prefer things to be unknown and mysterious and magical. As one of my professors put it: Bizarre Foods with Andrew Zimmern is orientalism; Anthony Bourdain’s No Reservations is not. Jessie is orientalism.

Ravi as a stereotypical Indian tourist, despite living in NYC

Ravi as a stereotypical Indian tourist, despite living in NYC

The idea that Ravi found a random lizard egg and decided to be best friends with it is one example of the orientalism used in this show. India does have a lot of wildlife, but it isn’t quite teeming with exotic creatures – one issue in India right now is how to protect the few tigers left on the planet, all of which live in India, mostly under precarious conditions. Especially since globalization, India is not really the image we have in our heads from Disney’s The Jungle Book, even though Disney is perpetuating this misconception through Ravi and Mr(s). Kipling’s friendship. We’re also exaggerating the influence Rudyard Kipling actually had on India. He traveled there a few times over a century ago; I’m pretty sure a random kid off the streets of India wouldn’t be naming his pet after him.

More importantly, even a “fresh off the boat” eight year old Indian kid who had not previously been exposed to American culture would not say things like “great Ganesh!” This isn’t a thing I have ever heard an Indian person say. I also don’t know any Indians who are constantly consulting their crystal balls and other magical ancient devices. A majority of the stereotypes Ravi embodies in the show aren’t even real stereotypes of India, so I really don’t understand why they are so prevalent. Also, how did an eight year old get certified to teach yoga? Is this also just because he is Indian?

Zuri giving a boy some attitude

Zuri giving a boy some attitude

Zuri was apparently adopted from Africa as a baby and raised by an upper-class white family. However, her catch phrases are things like “mmmmhmmmm” and “oh no you didn’t”, both said in a very stereotypically black way. She also has a major attitude problem that the adults never address, probably because they just assume all black people act that way.

The worst part about her character to me is that not just the stereotypes, but the fact that she is exhibiting urban black stereotypes despite never having been a part of urban black society. She lives in an Upper East Side penthouse and was born in Uganda. It is reminiscent of early 20th century ideas: things like social darwinism. These characteristics of Zuri exist in her genetics just because of the color of her skin.

Emma wearing pink and Luke being a sloppy boy

Emma and Luke are the two white children in the family. Emma is a typical “dumb blonde;” all she appears to be able to think about is boys, fashion, glitter, and celebrity gossip. She is constantly making ditzy comments and screaming high-pitched screams because she broke a nail. Luke is just a typical “boy,” which means he is always hitting on girls and using sexual innuendos. The sexual innuendos in themselves are in my opinion inappropriate for a children’s show; even if the target audience for these innuendos is parents, the children are the ones saying them. It isn’t just the innuendos in themselves, however – it’s that Luke’s character is perpetuating this idea that making degrading comments about girls’ bodies is okay, because it is just a “thing boys do.” Despite societal expectations, pretty blonde girls can care about more than looking good, and boys don’t have to constantly treat girls like objects.

The least offensive stereotype in this show is of Jessie. Since she’s from Texas, her dad is in the military and taught her how to shoot a gun when she was 5 years old. She also is always talking about how great Texas is. Typical Texan…

Recently, Disney Channel aired the worst episode of this show yet: “To Be or Not to Be.” In it, every character ends up switching bodies (a la Freaky Friday). If anyone had been watching the show and somehow didn’t realize how offensive all the stereotypes were, this episode makes it even more blatantly obvious. Jessie gets to put on a “black girl” accent (I didn’t even know there was a “black girl” accent?), and the butler does a terrible imitation of an Indian accent (think Ashton Kutcher Popchips ad, but worse). Wholesome Disney fun with hilarious racial stereotypes!

Edit: It just got even better. The new episode that aired 19 April 2013 has a women’s singer-songwriter show that Jessie is invited to perform at. Apparently the only people who would ever go to support aspiring female artists are other women – specifically, women who don’t shave their legs, hate all men, and wear ‘sensible shoes’. Hey, Jessie! You don’t have to hate men and fashion to be supportive of women. In fact, you can even be a man! And/or wear high heels!

Edit 2: This post originally stated that Mr. Kipling is a komodo dragon. This was false and clarified in a recent episode. I’m very sorry for providing you with false information and will do my best to make sure it doesn’t happen again. Feel free to correct me if you ever catch any more errors on my blog! Thanks 🙂

Advertisements

280 responses to “Why “Jessie” is the Worst Show on Disney Channel

  1. I know this is an old page, but I’d like to point out that Emma is the only white child of the group. The actor that places Luke is half Jewish and half black. Not white at all. But I can agree with everything else you’re saying

    • If your agreement means that you hate Jessie as kayfil and I do, then I congratulate you. In fact, I’m glad that it has no more new episodes. But unfortunately, it still airs on the Disney Channel in reruns. What’s just as bad is that my brother records it like there’s no tomorrow. And it drives me crazy. Therefore, I want it permanently removed from every network that it’s on. It’s just tiresome.

  2. Unbelievable! I didn’t know that you deleted every comment in this article of yours. But I’m guessing that’s because you couldn’t stand that many of them.

  3. Who the hell do you think you are, woman? You write about all your whiney liberal points about this show, pointing out all the stereotypes and then like a typical liberal Hypocrite, you do exactly what you yourself bitched about! Whine about Jessie being from Texas and always bragging about it “like a typical Texan”. People like you make me sick! I am from Texas and it’s not bragging when it’s True! Sorry that peoole from the rest of the states just don’t have much to brag about! I don’t even watch the show. My 5 year old son was watching it and I noticed Jessie was wearing a Texas Longhorn hoodie so I Googled the show to find out why and came across your little whiney blog. That is all. Now go be a good liberal and support Hitlary.

  4. Get your facts straight. Luke is NOT WHITE. He is bi-racial. His mother is white and his Dad is just “as black” as Zuri.

  5. Hey Kayfil, don’t you believe all stereotypes are bad? Yes? Well, you clearly don’t, you just perpetuated one in your article. You said that the stereotype that people from Texas all shoot guns and are part of the military is fully correct- nice try but no stereotypes should be accepted as true. You’d scream if someone said the stereotypes about Ravi or Zuri were true. It is clear that those stereotypes are NOT TRUE, but somehow you can’t see that your Texas stereotype isn’t as well?

    Defending characters against certain stereotypes then perpetuating others, what a hypocrite. Sucks you couldn’t leave out your thinly veiled hatred for other Americans from the south. You should never hate a certain type of people, that makes YOU prejudiced and intolerant.

    • A hypocrite? Are you fucking serious? Last time i checked, this stereotype about Texans doenst harm them, it doenst result in discrimnation or racism. How dare you compare that to racial stereotypes that uphold a racist system? How dare you try to minimize the meaning of this post with this cheap point.

Have something to say?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s